Pros and Cons of a Protected Trust Deed

Honest Overview

Pros and Cons

We believe in full transparency. Here is an honest look at the advantages and the real considerations of a Protected Trust Deed.

Advantages

  • Up to 90% of qualifying debt could be written off on completion
  • Legally binding - all included creditors must stop recovery action
  • Interest and charges on included debts are frozen immediately
  • One single affordable monthly payment replaces multiple debts
  • A fixed end date (typically 48 months) provides real certainty
  • Protection from court action, sheriff officers, and wage arrestment
  • You keep your home in most cases - equity may need to be addressed
  • Less severe than sequestration in terms of professional restrictions

Considerations

  • Your credit rating will be affected for 6 years from the start date
  • Recorded on the public Register of Insolvencies
  • If you own property, equity may need to be released in year four
  • Student loans, child maintenance, and secured debts cannot be included
  • Missing payments could ultimately lead to sequestration (bankruptcy)
  • Some regulated professions carry restrictions during formal insolvency
  • New credit over £500 requires your Trustee to be notified
  • Income and assets are subject to annual review for the full term
What to Watch For

Key Things to Look Out For

Before entering a Trust Deed, make sure you understand these six areas clearly so there are no surprises later.

Your Credit File - 6 Years from the Start

The Trust Deed stays on your credit file for 6 years from the start date, not the end date. Since the term is 48 months, the entry will still be visible to lenders for approximately 2 years after you are discharged. Plan any mortgage, finance, or rental applications around this timeline.

Home Equity in the Final Year

If you own property, your Trustee must assess and potentially realise equity, typically in year four. This could mean remortgaging or extending your payment period. Discuss your property situation explicitly with your IP before you sign the Trust Deed - not after.

Windfalls and Inheritances

If you receive a significant sum of money - inheritance, redundancy payment, personal injury award - during the Trust Deed, your Trustee may have a legal claim on part or all of it. This applies for the full term. Always notify your Trustee immediately if this happens.

Your Profession

Regulated roles in financial services, law, accountancy, and some civil service positions carry specific restrictions during formal insolvency proceedings. Check your employment contract and any professional body rules before you proceed. Your IP can help you understand the implications.

Excluded Debts Must Still Be Paid

Student loans, child maintenance, HMRC penalties, court fines, and secured debts (such as your mortgage) are excluded from the Trust Deed and remain your full responsibility throughout. Make sure you have a clear, funded plan for these before you start.

Annual Income Reviews Can Increase Payments

Every year your Trustee reviews your income. A significant pay rise, promotion, or new higher-paying job can result in your monthly contribution being increased for the remainder of the term. This is a normal part of the process but can surprise people who are not expecting it.

Questions to Ask

What to Consider Before Deciding

Use these four questions as a checklist when speaking to an Insolvency Practitioner for the first time.

?

Is this the right solution for me?

A PTD is one of several Scottish debt solutions. A Debt Arrangement Scheme, sequestration, or the Minimal Assets Process might be more appropriate depending on your income, assets, and total debt level. Ask your IP to explain all options before you decide.

?

Can I sustain the payments for 4 years?

Your monthly payment must be genuinely affordable for the full 48 months. Be honest about your budget - including irregular expenses such as car repairs, dental bills, and holidays - so the payment set is realistic and sustainable from day one.

?

What specifically happens to my home?

If you are a homeowner, ask your IP for their assessment of your equity situation and exactly how they plan to address it. Understanding the home equity process before you sign avoids a very unwelcome surprise in year four of your Trust Deed.

?

What are the trustee fees in full?

Ask for a complete written breakdown of how the Trustee is paid - fees come from your monthly contributions before creditors receive their share. A reputable IP provides a full fee statement in the proposal document. Do not proceed without reviewing this document carefully.

Next Steps

Ready to Find Out More?

The best way to decide whether a Trust Deed is right for you is a free, no-obligation assessment with a licensed Insolvency Practitioner who can review your full financial picture.

Use the Debt Calculator Compare All Solutions

Free Debt Advice - Available Now

Before making any decisions about a Protected Trust Deed, you are entitled to free, impartial debt advice from government-backed services. These services are completely free and have no obligation to use any particular product.

MoneyHelperGovernment-backed free money and debt guidance
moneyhelper.org.uk • 0800 138 7777
Citizens Advice ScotlandFree, confidential advice across Scotland
citizensadvice.org.uk/scotland
StepChange Debt CharityFree debt advice and debt management plans
stepchange.org • 0800 138 1111
National DebtlineFree advice for people in debt in Scotland
nationaldebtline.org • 0808 808 4000